| VA BENEFITS CAUGHT
IN RED TAPE, SYSTEM OVERWHELMED
"It is routine for the majority of
people to have some sort of major glitch with filing their claim."
NOTE from
Larry Scott, VA Watchdog dot Org
... Thanks to Amanda Carpenter for a great article.
What I find interesting is that
the VA would not be interviewed for this article. So much
for openness and transparency in government!
Be sure to watch the video
interview with veteran Jim Massey at the link below.
-------------------------
Veterans' benefits entangled in
red tape
by Amanda Carpenter
http://washingtontimes.com/news/2009/dec/31/veteran-benefits-
entangled-in-heaping-red-tape/?feat=home_headlines
Leading Democrats like to hold up the Veterans Benefits
Administration as an example of how well government can provide
health care. But veterans who deal with the complex federal
bureaucracy have invented an unhappy refrain to describe the VBA:
"Deny, deny until you die."
VBA, the branch of the Department of Veterans Affairs that
dispenses aid and assistance to veterans and their families, is
simply overwhelmed. It reported on Monday that there are 481,751
pending claims, some of which will take more than a year to be
processed.
Among those flooding the VBA's facilities with claims are
retirement-aged Vietnam veterans and elderly World War II
veterans, middle-aged Gulf War veterans, and younger Iraq and
Afghanistan veterans. All of these groups are applying in larger
numbers because of the weak economy, said Larry Scott, the founder
of the advocacy group VAwatchdog.org.
"You're getting a lot of people who came out of Vietnam and said,
'Excuse me, screw it.' They put their uniform away and didn't want
anything to do with the VA. Now they're getting older and know if
their boots were on the ground [in Vietnam], they were presumably
exposed to Agent Orange," Mr.
Scott
said, referring to the common name for a chemical defoliant widely
used in Vietnam that can cause cancer and other diseases.
"There is also great stress on the system because people who
qualified for private health insurance are now unemployed, or
underemployed and their employer doesn't provide health care. So
you've got all these people crawling out and saying, 'I didn't
know I could get this, but let me go see now.'"
Three government investigations released in September paint a
picture of an agency that simply can't keep up with the demand:
• An audit released Sept. 23 by the inspector general of Veterans
Affairs found that 3 percent of all claims took more than a year
for the VBA to process.
• A separate audit released Sept. 28, this one investigating VBA's
control of veterans' claims folders, said that 437,000 claims -
more than 10 percent of the 4.2 million on file - had been lost or
misplaced.
• In a third report, released Sept. 30, the inspector general said
employees at VA regional offices had shredded claims forms
containing information needed to obtain benefits. Although the
inspector general was unable to determine how many claims had been
wrongly destroyed, the investigation found claims placed in shred
bins, waiting to be destroyed, at 41 VBA locations nationwide.
Efforts to speak with someone at the VA about these matters on the
record were not fruitful. The only person the VA would make
available was a high-level technology officer at the VA, and that
interview was canceled twice at the last minute.
The VA did provide information to The Washington Times
attributable to a "VA spokesman," saying it hired an additional
4,200 people over the past three years to help reduce
claims-processing times and is testing a number of pilot programs
to streamline the process.
The VA also has put new controls in place to prevent workers from
shredding needed documents; two staffers and a facility records
management officer must now review a document before it can be
shredded.
But any improvement will come too late to help Greg Hasler, who
filed a disability claim with Veterans Affairs in May 2008 after
being diagnosed with a severe form of internal cancer. His
oncologist recognized it as a kind of cancer commonly caused by
radiation and said it likely was caused by Mr. Hasler's service in
the early 1960s in Operation Dominic at Christmas Island, a
Pacific Ocean atoll where many nuclear tests were conducted.
Mr. Hasler died from his fast-spreading cancer on Feb. 4, 2009, at
age 66. It wasn't until July that the VBA notified his wife that
it was examining the claim; the agency told her in September -
seven months after her husband's death - that his illness was
service-connected and that she was entitled to benefits.
Mrs. Hasler said she was able to get the claim opened only after
seeking help from advocates at VAwatchdog.org, who exposed her
problems with the VBA to the public as "the Case of the Atomic
Widow."
Other veterans, including former Vietnam helicopter pilot Jim
Massey, are still fighting for benefits. Mr. Massey has retained
legal counsel at his own expense after being spurned by the
system. He can barely walk because of his back problems but was
awarded a disability rating of only 20 percent, meaning the VA
thinks he still has 80 percent of his normal function.
Mr. Massey is appealing the ruling, but the process is
time-consuming and requires frequent appointments at far-away
military hospitals. His wife, Georgia, must schedule time off work
in order to drive her husband to the appointments since he cannot
drive himself.
Such problems are not uncommon, said Jim Strickland, one of the
two men who run VAwatchdog.org. "It is routine for the majority of
people to have some sort of major glitch with filing their claim,"
he said.
Mr. Massey, whose military awards include the Distinguished Flying
Cross, the Bronze Star and numerous Air Medals, first hurt his
back while serving as a door gunner in Vietnam when his helicopter
crashed from engine failure in November 1966.
He reinjured his back twice during his 20-year Army career, once
in 1972 lifting a heavy roll-up door of a helicopter hangar and
more severely in 1984 while extracting a fellow soldier from
concertina wire during a field exercise.
"Helicopters have vibrations, beats," said Mr. Massey, who served
as a helicopter pilot and test pilot for 13 years. "It vibrates
your head and just beats your neck and back continuously up and
down and side to side."
Since 2003, Mr. Massey has undergone 10 surgeries, five of which
have been on his lower back. Because of the "horror stories" he
had heard about the VA application process, he said, he delayed
filing for service-connected disability benefits until June 2007.
He was given a disability rating of just 20 percent even though he
has extreme difficulty walking and requires strong pain
medication, making it hard for him to seek a job. "I'm basically
housebound," Mr. Massey said.
He and his wife are now appealing, a process requiring tremendous
time and effort. Mrs. Massey, who keeps meticulous records, said
she took her husband to 69 doctor appointments in 2008 alone.
"One time, they just measured the scars on my back," Mr. Massey
said, after traveling 240 miles to be evaluated by the VA.
Mr. Massey was notified by mail about when and where to appear
next and was not given any choices. Paperwork from his VA medical
center warned: "Failure to report for any scheduled examination
could have a detrimental effect on the outcome of your claim."
In August, Mr. Massey received a mind-boggling letter from the VA.
"We propose to rate you as incompetent for VA purposes," it said.
"Evidence from your VA psychiatric examination dated February 6,
2008, revealed you stated that your short-term memory is quite
poor, and your wife often makes you a list that you at times will
even forget to read or follow through on.
"You said that you lose objects regularly, including telephone,
camera, keys, and stated this has been going on for the past six
to seven years. The examiner stated on the basis of this
evaluation, you appeared minimally to partially capable of
managing your VA benefits."
Mr. Massey worries that such a ruling would mean someone else
would be appointed to manage his personal finances. "Who doesn't
misplace items?" he asked.
Mr. Strickland has advised the Masseys to seek legal counsel,
which they have done. "All I am asking for is fair compensation
for the injuries my body and mind received during my 20 years of
service in the defense of our country," Mr. Massey said.
Drew Early, a veterans lawyer based in Decatur, Ga., who is
working with the Masseys, said it is not unusual to be threatened
with a finding of incompetency.
"Any time they see anything that looks like it could be dementia
or Alzheimer's, that rings a bell in their head, and they will
automatically default to a finding of incompetency, which in and
of itself can be harming," he said.
"The problem is that this is a federal agency making a
determination that has many ramifications beyond the scope of the
VA. They can extend it to say you can't own a gun. 'We are a
federal agency and we are declaring you incompetent,' and that has
baggage throughout [an individual's] life and engagement with the
government."
Such findings are difficult for a veteran to appeal.
"An enemy combatant in Guantanamo Bay has more rights than does a
veteran," Mr. Early said. "And who has the time? These poor
veterans don't have time to sit and wait and confront the nation's
second-largest bureaucracy. They are in need of help, but this
bureaucratic fortress stands in their way."
Mr. Massey hopes eventually to be rated as 100 percent disabled,
but regrets having to work so hard to get the rating to which he
feels entitled.
Mrs. Hasler, the "atomic widow," is similarly upset that she had
to get help from the men at VAwatchdog.org to receive compensation
from the military that her husband served before dying prematurely
from that service.
She said it "unnerved" her having to share the details of her
husband's untimely death with other people, but "the one thing he
made me promise was that I would not give up on the claim" that
could provide her with payments on which to live.
"I'm a relatively private person, and the average person doesn't
know where to go, and there is certainly no handbook from the VA
to guide you," she said. "I don't think they give a rip."
------------------------- |